…Sudan’s clerics, over this week’s case of Mohammed the bear. In brief, British teacher Gillian Gibbons, teaching in Sudan, asked students to propose names for the adorable white bear, then vote on a name. They chose Mohammed, provoking a furore and resulting in Gibbons being charged with inciting religious hatred, since it would be an insult to Islam’s prophet to name an animal — even, it seems, a toy one — after him. Even though it was the students, mostly Muslim, who put the name on the ballot and then voted for it, Sudan’s top crackheads clerics called the incident part of a broader Western plot against Islam and called for the full weight of the law — up to 40 lashes, six months in prison and a fine — to be brought against Gibbons.
The Sudanese Foreign Ministry is playing the incident down, and may their less confused minds prevail. In all likelihood neither the students nor their teacher were aware of their transgression. Children tend to anthropomorphise toys — a teddy bear is a stand-in for a person, not a stand-in for a bear. They may have thought of family members and friends with the name of Mohammed, which is used a lot more widely as a name in the Islamic world than Jesus in the Christian world. Maybe their prophet’s name even seemed a natural choice for the white, benevolent-looking teddy.
The incident reminds me of my run-in with Mrs Catford in prep grade. I drew God in the way my little heart responded to the idea, as a spirit pervading everything, with clouds for hair and a row of red flowers for a mouth. Mrs Catford reprimanded me fiercely, with a sincere anger that astonished me since I had never encountered a religious zealot before, for not drawing God as an old man in a bathrobe. “He’s meant to look like Hugh Hefner,” she said. (Okay, she didn’t really.) After that I liked neither Mrs Catford nor God, since the latter had not come to my defense with a lightning bolt.
Fortunately, Mrs Catford’s power didn’t extend beyond our classroom. Nothing seems to bring out the really barmy side of people more than religion. Without denying that in past times the world’s great religions had some beneficial influence on government, those times are long gone. Any time I hear our leaders in the west speaking out about the importance of their faith, I get nervous. When not kept separate from the state, religion too easily swells from being a carrot and stick arrangement in people’s minds, not entirely useless in having an ability to promote social justice, to being a creepy, reality-deprived end in itself. Even a bear with very little brain can see that.
Update 30/11/07:
Gibbons was convicted of the lesser crime of insulting Islam and sentenced to 15 days and deportation. The British Foreign Office said it was very disappointed and summoned the Sudanese ambassador to explain the verdict. Weak.