Dr Emo
Thursday, May 29th, 2008After sitting through yet another goes-to-11-on-the-emotometer episode of Dr Who (The Doctor’s Daughter — spoilers below), I find myself asking why I still watch a show that almost never fails to make me squirm at least once per episode, not from sheer, clean terror as I used to as a kid, but from embarrassment at some piece of incontinently squirting emo-ness. The answer is, of course, that both Christopher Eccleston and David Tennant were and are respectively charismatic enough to make even a badly scripted show watchable, and the aliens are usually pretty cool (I say usually; we were not well served by seeing the Sontarans, once sinister and as scary as potatoes in spacesuits can be, dancing a retarded imitation of a Haka).
Not that the new Dr Who is all badly scripted. But there is a godawful tendency for the writers to make the characters voice everything in their minds and hearts. One of the facts about film and television is that everything doesn’t have to be said, and in the case of strong feelings, a little script tends to go a long way. Moreover, with a long-running show like Dr Who, I think the writers must keep in mind the fact that hearts disclosed can’t be undisclosed. You can’t drop the same bomb twice. Viewers do remember what took place in previous episodes. New companions don’t have to be told, on camera, what we already know. We know the Doctor fought in the Time War. We know all the other Time Lords died. We know he carries terrible emotional scars from the experience. We also know that since the beginning of the series he has not been in the habit of talking about his personal problems. This is part of what makes him mysterious and cool. In the old series there was ongoing, never-released tension in our not knowing much about his past other than that there was some trouble in it. The Time War is an extra Big Bad, but as with most Big Bads in a character’s past that are not a subject of current investigation, the shadowier the details, the better. In this respect the Doctor is like the Man With No Name (yeah, I had to mention him…). You know the guy’s been through hard times. There’s dignity, and some pathos, in his preference for not talking about those times. The Doctor’s Daughter gave us an almost-but-not-quite Time Lord girl made from the Doctor’s DNA. With a restrained script, we viewers would have been able to imagine the Doctor’s feelings quite well. Instead, the Doctor is prodded into coming out of his shell for a few moments in which we get a reiteration of how he fought and killed and lost everyone; and to top it all off, the girl gets shot dead, seemingly just to provide a scene full of angst, which turns out to be disposable angst, since she gets better, Monty Python style, after the Doctor and Donna depart.
Part of the problem is, ironically, that in the one hour format there isn’t much time for chit chat, so that emotional explorations are always quickies–there’s no time for us to build up to the moment. Discussions of a personal nature get squeezed into gaps between action, ruining the tension. How worried can the characters be if they’re playing therapist between one firefight and the next? We get the worst of both worlds. And another gripe — what’s with the in-show squeeing? Why is Donna being made to fangirl over the Doctor, especially as she’s given to nagging him quite a bit about his faults? I hope it’s because he’s going to do something that will screw severely with her idea of him…
Christopher Eccleston said he wanted to add an emotional weight to the role, saying that a modern audience “turn on the television to look into people’s souls”. That was a worthy aim, but one which the writers have thus far not done much to abet — or rather, they’ve added emotional weight, but mainly in the form of wobbly fat, not firm muscle. (I’m not the only one who thinks the new Who is a bit quivery.) This isn’t to say that characters should never disclose their feelings, but to have them do so every episode drags the show down to the level of soap opera. A long-running show requires some thought to the timing of the buildup and release of tension, even when each episode is self-contained. Where the writers do pay attention to this — as they did with the Rose Tyler arc — it works. And they didn’t over-script the emotionally heavy moments, either.
Also successful was, I think, the Doctor’s unexpected and brief reunion with Sarah Jane Smith. And I think it worked because the tension was already pre-built, at least for viewers of the old series (and Elisabeth Sladen played it perfectly, too). But too often the arrows are being made to fly without the bow being properly drawn. I think much could be improved if the series were taken back to a four hour format. The one hour format is conducive to rush and muddle of all kinds.
I will now go sit on the porch and glare lumpishly at the young folk.